Absolute Discharge and Conditional Discharge

Consult our Lawyers

What Is a Discharge?

A discharge is a sentencing option under section 730 of the Criminal Code that allows a person who has been found guilty of an offence to avoid a criminal conviction.

In practical terms, the court recognizes the person’s guilt but chooses not to register a conviction. As a result, the individual is considered not to have a criminal record, subject to certain legal nuances.

There are two types of discharges:

  • l’absolution inconditionnelleAbsolute discharge: no conditions are imposed;
  • l’absolution conditionnelleConditional discharge: the person must comply with specific conditions (probation).

This outcome is often highly sought after in criminal law because it helps avoid the long-term consequences of a criminal record, including impacts on employment, travel, and reputation.

Contact Us
procuring-image
procuring-image

When Can a Discharge Be Granted?

A discharge is not available in every case.

To be eligible:

  • The offence must not carry a mandatory minimum sentence;
  • It must not be punishable by 14 years or more of imprisonment, or life imprisonment.

In addition, the court must be satisfied of two key elements:

  • That granting a discharge is in the best interests of the accused;
  • And that it is not contrary to the public interest.

This requires a careful balancing exercise, taking into account both the personal circumstances of the accused and the broader impact on public confidence in the justice system.

Contact Us

The Two Types of Discharge

Absolute Discharge

An absolute discharge is the most favorable outcome.

No conditions are imposed. The matter is quickly resolved, and after a certain administrative period, there is no active record remaining.

This type of discharge is typically considered where:

  • The offence is isolated;
  • The accused has a strong personal profile;
  • The risk of reoffending is low.
Conditional Discharge

A conditional discharge involves a probation order.

The accused must comply with certain conditions for a specified period, such as:

  • Keeping the peace and being of good behaviour;
  • Attending counselling or treatment programs;
  • Avoiding certain people or places.

If the conditions are successfully completed, the discharge takes full effect.

However, if the conditions are breached, the court may revoke the discharge and impose a sentence.annuler l’absolution et imposer une peine.

procuring-image

Important Considerations

Even with a discharge:

  • Additional court orders may still apply (e.g., prohibitions);
  • Probation conditions may be in place (for a conditional discharge);
  • Any breach can lead to serious consequences.

It is also important to understand that not all offences are suitable for a discharge, particularly where the conduct is serious or prolonged.

Contact Us

Practical Example

A university student with no prior criminal record is found guilty of shoplifting items worth $150 from a retail store.

They cooperated with police, reimbursed the store, expressed genuine remorse, and are pursuing a career where a criminal record would significantly limit future opportunities.

In these circumstances, the court may determine that a discharge is appropriate to support rehabilitation while remaining consistent with the public interest.

Contact Us
procuring-image

Defence Strategy and Discharge

Obtaining a discharge often depends on how well the case is presented.

It is essential to demonstrate:

The real impact of a criminal record;

Efforts toward rehabilitation;

Personal and professional stability;

A low risk to the community.

A well-prepared case can significantly increase the chances of avoiding a conviction.

A Key Point Not to Overlook

To fully benefit from a discharge, it is often important to request:

  • No court costs;
  • No victim surcharge.

This helps ensure that financial obligations do not undermine the practical advantages of the discharge.

Why Consult a Criminal  Defence Lawyer?

Every case is unique, and a discharge is never automatic.

A criminal defence lawyer can:

Assess whether you are eligible for a discharge;
Build a strong and persuasive case;
Present tailored arguments before the court;
Maximize your chances of avoiding a criminal record.

Contact Lesperance Avocats

Do you have questions? Are you looking for criminal lawyers who accept legal aid mandates? Contact us now!

Submit
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

You Don’t Have to Face This Alone

A single conversation can give you clarity and direction. Contact us now and we'll help you understand your options and take the next step with confidence.

Contact Us
PicturePicture
Back-top